~ CHAPTER 8 ~ HABITAT DEGRADATION ~
Edition 9 of October 2009 (Updated October 2010)

~ TABLE OF CONTENTS ~

(8-A) ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ [A1]~Pollution Economics, [A2]~Oil Discharges, [A3]~Red Tides/Algae Blooms, [A4]~Oxygen Depletion, [A5]~Bacteria, [A6]~Tumors, [A7]~Toxic Discharges, [A8]~Ballast Discharges, ~
(8-B) ~
Exotic (introduced) Species ~
(8-C) ~
Physical Habitat Degradation ~ [C1]~Bottom-Trawling and Dredging, [C2]~Factory Trawlers, [C3]~Dams, [C4]~Food Supply, [C5]~Habitat Elimination, ~
(8-D) ~
Atmospheric Effects ~ [D1]~Ozone, [D2]~Ocean Temperatures, [D3]~Acid Precipitation, ~
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fi8
NOTE: The notation (su5) means that the data is used in the document analyzing the sustainability of the productivity of the world's food, fiber and water supply systems. (See elsewhere in this website.)

SECTION (8-A) ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ [A1]~Pollution Economics, [A2]~Oil Discharges, [A3]~Red Tides/Algae Blooms, [A4]~Oxygen Depletion, [A5]~Bacteria, [A6]~Tumors, [A7]~Toxic Discharges, [A8]~Ballast Discharges, ~

Sources of marine pollution as listed in GESAMP's "The State of the Marine Environment" (93W1)
Runoff and discharge from land~ ~ ~ ~|44 wt.%
Airborne emissions from land~ ~ ~ ~ ~|33
Shipping and accidental spills~ ~ ~ ~|12
Ocean Dumping ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~|10
Off-shore mining and oil/gas drilling| 1

Comments: Estuarine pollution has a much different make-up.

The 10 types of marine pollution, the primary source/ cause of each, and the effects are listed on p.18 of Ref. (93W1).

Part [A1] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Pollution Economics ~

Since the middle of the 1980s phosphorus loads have generally leveled off or declined locally. In some areas such as the North Sea there have been declines in P content by up to 50% due to improved sewage treatment, reduced industrial discharges and a change to phosphorus-free detergents (03F1). However, there do not yet seem to be discernible European-scale reduction of nitrogen inputs, marine eutrophication or extent of anoxic areas (02K1) (07A1).

Cambodia has no sewage treatment facilities outside the capital Phnom Penh (06B1).

In Indonesia just 3% of urban areas area connected to sewerage systems (06B1).

In China, the world's most populous country, more than 300-million people live within 100 km of a coast, yet China has the capacity to treat less than 50% of its wastewater (06B1).

Secondary treatment of municipal sewage removes at least 85% of the organic material and suspended solids in wastewater, but only 33% of nitrogen and phosphorus (the principal causes of eutrophication). Advanced treatment technologies capable of eliminating up to 97% of N and 99% of P are being implemented in some areas (01B3).

Most economists have agreed that "externalities" -that is effects not normally accounted for in the cost-revenue analyses of producers - are the leading economic cause of pollution (73C1).

Dag Nullah (a freshwater lake in Pakistan) once yielded 400 tonnes of fish/ year. It is now barren, destroyed by pollution (93B1).

A third of US shellfish beds are closed, primarily because of pollution (EPA Journal (Sept.-Oct.1990)).

Half of the shellfish-growing areas off Nova Scotia have been closed because of contamination (Ref.18 of (93B1)).

Some 69% of US shellfish-growing waters were approved for harvest in 1995, vs. 58% in 1985 ((98A1), p. 6).

Currently, environmental degradation of the marine environment is depressing total annual landings by 3-5% (Ref. 3 of (98W1)) compared to losses due to over-fishing on the order of 10-15%. This effect will become more important if general environmental degradation continues. The potential exists for these losses to become greater than the losses that the fishing industry causes (Ref. 4 of (98W1)).

Worldwide, an NRC panel estimated, 70% of marine oil pollution comes from fuel users, not producers or shippers. The academy's findings echo a growing consensus in recent years that "non-point" pollution, from countless dispersed sources, poses one of the nation's most serious and intractable environmental problems. The study, by 14 scientists and engineers, including some from the oil industry, was produced by the National Research Council. The NRC is the branch of the National Academy of Sciences that conducts independent studies for the government (02R3). While emphasizing the problem of oil pollution in runoff, the report noted a sharp drop in the number and volume of accidental spills by tankers and barges in American waters since the Valdez grounding. Humans release about 210 million gallons of petroleum a year into the seas, the report said, while natural seepage adds 180 million gallons (02R3).

Part [A2] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Oil Discharges ~

The Exxon Valdez spilled 11 million gallons of oil into the ocean. A city of 5 million people generates that much run-off each year. Large oil spills only account for 10% of the oil ending up in the ocean each year. About 706 million gallons of oil gets in the ocean each year via used engine oil being poured down the drain, runoff from city streets, air pollution particles and offshore oil drilling. So who's dumping oil down the drain? -363 million gallons of it ends up in our waterways due to this reason alone. Ship operations account for over 137 million gallons entering oceans and waterways (annually?). Oil tankers spill 37 million gallons/ year, and another 15 million spill from off shore oilrig operations. Millions of gallons of jet- and aircraft fuel spills each year, on land and in water ("Valdez a Drop in the Bucket?" Env. News Service (3/20/00)).

Despite international bans, ships discharge 5-50 million tons of oil at sea per year. More than 0.7 million tonnes are spilled into the Mediterranean per year (Ref. 44 of (99M1)).

The Exxon Valdez spilled 11 million gallons of oil into the ocean. A city of 5 million people generates that much run-off each year. Large oil spills only account for 10% of oil ending up in the ocean. 706 million gallons of oil gets in the ocean each year via used engine oil being poured down the drain, runoff from city streets, air pollution particles and offshore oil drilling. So who's dumping oil down the drain? - 363 million gallons of it ends up in our waterways due to this reason alone. Ship operations account for more than 137 million gallons entering oceans and waterways (annually?). Oil tankers spill 37 million gallons/ year, and another 15 million spill from off shore oil rig operations. Millions of gallons of jet- and aircraft fuel spill each year, on land and in water (Env. News Service (3/20/00)).

A 1985 US National Research Council study of oil in the sea found that 21 million barrels/ year enter the oceans from street runoff, ships flushing tanks, and effluent from industrial facilities (89L1). Some 600,000 barrels/ year enter the oceans from accidental spills. As little as 0.1 ppm oil in sea water has serious effects on the reproduction and growth of fish, crustaceans and plankton (89L1). Phytoplankton and zooplankton, the base of the oceanic food chain, congregate in the top 0.01" of the ocean, as do some fish and shellfish in the early stages of their lives (89L1).

The US and Canada have each banned oil drilling on large portions of their continental shelves (99M1).

Runoff and routine maintenance of oil infrastructure are estimated to account for over 70% of total oil discharged into the oceans ((85N1) p. 82).

Most oil pollution in North American coastal waters comes not from leaking tankers or oil rigs, but rather from countless oil-streaked streets, sputtering lawn mowers and other dispersed sources on land, and so will be hard to prevent, a panel convened by the National Academy of Sciences says in a new report. The thousands of tiny releases, carried by streams and storm drains to the sea, are estimated to equal an Exxon Valdez spill - 10.9 million gallons of petroleum - every eight months, the report says (02R3). (Continued below)

When fuel use on water, either inland or offshore, is also taken into account, the report says, about 85% of the 29 million gallons of marine oil pollution in North America each year comes from users - drivers, businesses, boaters - not from the oil industry. Spills from tankers, barges and other oil transport vessels totaled less than a quarter-million gallons in 1999, down from more than six million in 1990. The shift follows a substantial tightening of environmental regulations on oil exploration and shipping since the grounding of the Exxon Valdez in 1989. The new report is the academy's third examination of marine oil pollution since 1975, but the first since the Exxon Valdez spill (02R3). Oil carried in runoff is particularly damaging, the report said, because it typically ends up discharged by rivers and streams into bays and estuaries that "are often some of the most sensitive ecological areas along the coast" (02R3).

Part [A3] ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Red Tides / Algae Blooms ~

A massive red tide that paralyzed shellfish farms near Puerto Montt in southern Chile, is regarded by some as further evidence of the effects of salmon farming. The algal bloom has been causing chaos in the Tenth Region since the end of March, particularly around the Chiloé Island area, where the economy depends greatly on seafood production. There are 240 shellfish farms around Chiloé alone, producing 20,000 tonnes of raw material and employing 900 people directly. The bloom produces toxins related to Alexandrium catenella, which gives rise to paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) in bivalve molluscs such as oysters, mussels, sea asparagus and clams. It has spread from further south in Chile and the health authorities have closed all shellfish landing ports and introduced controls on beaches, production and processing areas and on the roads. Red tides have been observed in Chile since the beginning of the 19th Century but were confined to the southernmost part of the country. They have now begun moving northwards and are being registered in the waters of the Tenth Region for the first time. Environmental groups claim that eutrophication of the sea by farmed salmon is responsible for the phenomenon. However, the red tide has been a disaster for salmon farmers too, with 1.5 million salmon having died in one farm alone, according to El Llanquihue of Puerto Montt. A report in Ecoceanosnews stated that in 1998 there was a harmful algal bloom of the Heterosigma akashiwo species that destroyed huge numbers of salmon. The highest concentrations of toxins were registered around the salmon farms, with up to 22,000 micrograms found per 100 milligrams of meat. The maximum allowance is 80 micrograms per 100mg of shellfish meat. These figures were as high as those registered in Magallanes where red tides have been appearing for the last 15 years (Albert Arias Arthur, "Red tide spreads chaos'" (Chile) www.FIS.com (4/12/02)).

A massive red tide, which paralyzing shellfish farms near Puerto Montt in southern Chile, is regarded by some as further evidence of the effects of salmon farming. There are 240 shellfish farms around Chiloé alone, producing 20,000 tonnes of raw material and employing 900 people directly. Red tides have been observed in Chile since the beginning of the 19th Century but were confined to the southernmost part of Chile. They have now begun moving northwards. Environmental groups claim that eutrophication of the sea by farmed salmon is responsible for the phenomenon. However, the red tide has been a disaster for salmon farmers too, with 1.5 million salmon having died in one farm alone (Albert Arias Arthur, "Red tide spreads chaos (Chile) FIS Latino, www.FIS.com (4/12/02)).

A report in Ecoceanosnews stated that in 1998 there was a harmful algal bloom of the Heterosigma akashiwo species that destroyed huge numbers of salmon. The highest concentrations of toxins were registered around the salmon farms, with up to 22,000 micrograms found per 100 milligrams of meat. The maximum allowance is 80 micrograms per 100 mg of shellfish meat. These figures were as high as those registered in Magallanes where a red tide has been appearing for the last 15 years (Albert Arias Arthur, "Red tide spreads chaos (Chile) FIS Latino, www.FIS.com (4/12/02)).

Significant seagrass losses caused by excessive nutrient loadings have been observed in bays and coastal lagoons in New England, the mid-Atlantic region, Florida, Texas, California, Europe, Australia and Japan (01B3) (95D2).

Extensive exploitation of menhaden and oysters (both filter feeders) is linked to increased eutrophication of the Chesapeake ecosystem in the US (02D5). It takes the present-day oyster population of Chesapeake Bay 6-12 months to filter the same volume of water that it once could filter in a matter of days (02D5).

Harmful Algal Blooms in the West Central Atlantic during 1970-96 (Ref. 33 of (99M1)) (from a smoothed plot)
Year ~|1970|1975|1980|1985|1990|1995
Number| 20 | 35 | 60 | 110| 180| 250

One common problem in estuaries is the occurrence of major "blooms" of phytoplankton caused (probably) by excess nutrients from rivers (excess fertilizer, sewage, soil sediments, etc.) (90C2). These blooms kill fish and other aquatic life. Blooms have endangered salmon in Swedish mariculture, dolphins off the Carolinas, fish life along the German coast of the North Sea, swimming beaches and fishnets on the Adriatic Sea (90C2). On a small scale, blooms are part of the natural cycle of the sea, at least in temperate areas. Nutrients from human activity change these small blooms into massive outbreaks (90C2).

Red tides are described in an article by Donald M. Anderson, Scientific American, 271(2) (August 1994) pp. 62-69.

Nutrients washed into the sea from pollution on land feed algae that cause "blooms". As these algae decompose, oxygen is badly depleted, causing fish kills. Toxic blooms ("Red Tides") have been found to correlate well in location and time with nutrient levels (89L1).

When algae blooms die, they deplete the oxygen over large areas of water, creating "dead zones" where nothing can live (97F1).

[A3a] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Red Tides / Algae Blooms ~ North America ~

During 1991-1998, algal blooms in the US have caused nearly $300 million in economic losses in the form of fish kills, public health problems, lost tourism and seafood revenues (Ref. 38 of (99M1)).

In the US, harmful algae blooms have caused nearly $300 million in economic damages since 1991 from fish kills, public health problems and lost revenues from tourism and the seafood industry ((99M1), p. 25). From the 1970s to the 1990s, the frequency of harmful algae blooms has increased from 200 to 700 incidents/year ((99N3), p. 52). Some of this may just be better reporting ((00W3), p. 81).

The number of phytoplankton cells in the upper Chesapeake Bay has increased by 250 times since the 1950s. The result has been a rise in the number of algal blooms: areas of water blanketed with algae. Between 1950-80, the amount of water in the main part of Chesapeake Bay which had little or no oxygen increased by 15 times. During the summer, most water deeper than 40 ft. from the Annapolis Bay Bridge to the Rappahannock River contains no oxygen, and is therefore devoid of life. [In 1980 59% of Chesapeake Bay watershed was forested, 26% was agricultural, 15% was industrial, commercial or residential.]~ (The Environmental Fund data, May 1984).

Since 1972 the east coast of the US (Mass. to North Carolina) had 6 major toxic blooms. Bloom-contaminated shellfish can be deadly (89L1).

"Harmful Algae blooms" include pfiesteria, red tides that closed down the Gulf of Mexico's shellfish industry in 1996, brown tides that periodically wipe out Long Island's scallop industry, and paralytic shellfish poisoning which affects the shellfish industry of the West Coast of the US. Many of the one-celled creatures involved in algae blooms are harmless until they come into contact with chemicals found in abundance near land. Then their populations explode and throw off a family of poisons that can cause lesions and kill fish. In humans these creatures can also cause skin lesions and short-term memory losses in those who come into contact with the water or inhale the spray (97F1).

In a 1991 North Carolina fish-kill caused by a pfisteria bloom, sewage from large hog farms appeared to be one of the causes of the bloom (97F1). Politicians ridiculed the scientist's findings and threatened to cut off funding for the research - until an October 1995 bloom wiped out 15 million fish (97F1).

Scientists studying a dead zone at the bottom of Chesapeake Bay suspect chicken manure from huge poultry operations on Maryland's Eastern Shore (97F1).

The large dead zone in the Gulf of Mexico is believed to result from nitrogen coming down the Mississippi River from upper Midwestern US agricultural runoff (97F1).

The dead zone in the Gulf of Mexico due to agricultural runoff in the Mississippi River basin causing algae blooms that deplete the water's oxygen is now 17,600 km2 in size (State of the World 1998, p. 53).

More than $13 million was appropriated for FY1998 to fund US federal-agency efforts to understand, and possibly control, blooms thought to be caused by Pfiesteria (98B2).

[A3b] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Red Tides / Algae Blooms ~ Asia ~

A March 1998 bloom of Gyrodinium aureolum algae in Hong Kong killed 1500 tons of farmed fish, and contaminated surviving schools with toxins, leading to an advisory to avoid eating sea fish. Over 350 tons of fish were also killed in China's waters. The kill was equivalent to 50% of fish production in the territory in 1997 (Reuters, 4/11+17+24/98) (iatp@iatp.org, 4/24/98).

In the Seto inland sea of Japan "red tides" increased from 40/ year in 1965 to over 300/ year in 1973. In 1976 Japanese authorities introduced controls designed to cut nutrients entering the sea by 50%. The frequency of red tides peaked in 1975 and have been declining ever since (90C2) (Ref. 22 of (93W1)). (NOTE: This is evidence that "blooms" are the result of human pollution - not some unexplained oceanic phenomena.)

An outbreak of red tide off Azuma-cho, Kagoshima Prefecture could spell disaster for the area, Japan's prime area for yellowtail culture. Some 300 sea farming cages, containing 400,000 fish, were hit by the red tide on 8/24/02. The last red tide in the area, in 1990, killed 24,000 fish resulting in a loss of JPY 30 million. But the current outbreak may be the worst case ever seen in the Yatsuhiro Sea, and losses this time could exceed JPY 300 million. The red tide is composed of a species of phytoplankton. The Azuma-cho cooperative association boasts Japan's highest production volumes of 10-13,000 tonnes/ year (Haruo Chiba FIS Asia, "Red tide spells disaster for Yellowtail farming" (Japan)www.FIS.com (8/28/02)).

[A3c] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Red Tides / Algae Blooms ~ Europe ~

Algae blooms in the Adriatic Sea have killed fish in areas as large as 400 mi2 (1000 km2) (89L1).

In May, 1988, a toxic algae bloom in the Skagemak (connects North Sea to Baltic Sea) killed fish valued at $200 million (89L1). The bloom was traced to urban and agricultural pollution (89L1).

[A3d] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Red Tides / Algae Blooms ~ South America ~

Red tides have been observed in Chile since the beginning of the 19th Century but were confined to the southernmost part of the country. They are now moving northwards. Environmental groups blame eutrophication of the sea by farmed salmon. Red tides have been a disaster for salmon farmers too. A report in Ecoceanosnews stated that, in 1998, an algal bloom of the Heterosigma akashiwo species destroyed huge numbers of salmon. The highest concentrations of toxins were registered around salmon farms, with up to 22 mg per 100 mg. of meat. (The maximum allowance is 0.080 mg. per 100 mg. of shellfish meat.) ("Red tide spreads chaos", (Chile) www.FIS.com 4/12/02)

Part [A4] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Oxygen Depletion ~

The dead zone in the Gulf of Mexico near the mouth of the Mississippi River was first recorded in the early 1970s. It now occurs annually. The low oxygen levels (2 parts per million) in the zone make the water uninhabitable for fish and other marine life. The average size of the dead zone over the past five years (2002-2006) has been 6,000 square miles. (The article tabulates the size of the dead zone during the period 1985 to 2006.) These zones are caused by an increase in chemical nutrients, usually nitrogen or phosphorous from fertilizer. Commercial and recreational Gulf fisheries generate about $2.6 billion per year. (Alyssa Cultice, "Gulf of Mexico Dead Zone," Louisiana Universities Marine Consortium (10/20/09))

In the Black Sea up to 90% of the waters are anoxic. The Kattegat has been affected by seasonal hypoxia since the beginning of the 1980s, which has followed a more than 3-fold increase in nitrogen input in the 1960s and 1970s (90R1). Similarly, in the north Adriatic Sea, the first signs of hypoxia started around 1960 and developed into severe anoxic events over the past 20 years (95B3), (01D1) (07A1).

A study of coastal ecosystems in 2006 found that over-fishing of predator fish, rather than pollution and global warming, is the probable cause of oceanic "dead zones." Dead zones are found in the Gulf of Mexico, Chesapeake Bay and in the Baltic and Adriatic seas, and they are spreading to the open oceans (08G1).

The main cause of "dead zones" is nitrogen-rich nutrients from crop fertilizers spilling into coastal waters via rivers and streams (08V1) (08B1).

The number of "dead zones" globally has doubled about every 10 years since the 1960s. About 405 coastal areas (mainly estuaries) now have periodically oxygen-starved bottom waters, many of which are growing in size and intensity. In the 1960s the number was 49 (08V1) (08B1).

In the Kattegat Sea dead zone, Norway's lobster fishery collapsed (08V1) (08B1).

The dead zone at the mouth of the Mississippi River in the Gulf of Mexico has more than doubled in size during the past 20 years (08V1) (08B1).

The mechanism of dead zone creation and growth is that nitrogen from agricultural runoff and sewage stimulates the growth of photosynthetic plankton on the surface of coastal waters. As these organisms decay and sink to the bottom, they are decomposed by microbes that consume large amounts of oxygen. As oxygen levels drop, most animals that live on the bottom cannot survive. Many dead zones are cyclical, recurring each year in the summer months (08V1) (08B1).

Low oxygen levels also kill annelid worms and other low-trophic-level sources for food for fish and crustaceans (08V1) (08B1).

Sound agricultural practices can help to avoid dead zones and reduce soil erosion at the same time. One such practice is the planting of winter rye or winter wheat rather than leaving fields fallow after the fall harvest. Such plantings cause much fertilizer to be absorbed by the winter crops rather than being leached into the waterways by spring rains (08V1) (08B1).

The world's largest dead zone is in the Baltic Sea, whose bottom waters now lack oxygen year around (08V1) (08B1).

Roughly 83,000 tons (75,000 tonnes) of fish and other life are lost to the Chesapeake dead zone every year (08V1) (08B1).

More than 212,000 tonnes of food is lost to hypoxia in the Gulf of Mexico (every year) (08V1) (08B1).

The number of reported hypoxic (low oxygen) zones is growing globally at a rate of 5%/ year (08D1).

The number of "dead zones" has risen to more than 140 in 2004 from almost none until the late 1970s (08D1).

Global warming may aggravate the problem of "dead zones," partly because oxygen dissolves less readily in warmer water (08D1).

The first "dead zones" were found in the Chesapeake Bay on the US east coast and in Scandinavian fjords. Since then, others have been found off South America, Ghana, China, Japan, Australia, New Zealand, Portugal and Great Britain (08D1).

The usual standard for oxygen level in a "dead zone" has been 2.0 mg./ liter of sea water or less. However some species start suffering at oxygen levels of 8.6 mg. (just below the normal oxygen level in seawater). As a result, scientists have been urging that a revised standard of 4.6 mg./ liter of seawater be set (08D1).

Nitrogen and phosphate farm chemical fertilizer runoff is creating "dead zones" in oceans around the world and the problem is likely to increase by 2/3 by 2050. There are already more than 50 dead zones in the world - including the Gulf of Mexico, Chesapeake Bay and Puget Sound -caused by an abundance of nutrients choking off oxygen (Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 3/30/05, 219 pp. (a 5-year study commissioned by the UN) See www.millenniumassessment.org). (Also in this author's cropland degradation review document.)

There are at least 200 oxygen-starved "dead zones" in the world's seas, an increase of more than 33% during the two-year period 2005 and 2006. Algae blooms that suck up oxygen and cause dead zones are triggered by phosphorus and nitrogen from fertilizer, sewage, animal waste, and fossil fuel burning. Dead zones lurk off the coasts of the US, Scandinavia, South America, Ghana, China, Japan, Australia, New Zealand, Portugal, and Britain. Dead-zone problems are getting worse; nitrogen pollution of waterways and oceans is expected to rise 14% during the period from the mid 90's to 2030 ("UN Reports Increasing 'Dead Zones' in Oceans," Boston Globe (10/19/06).). (su5)

Hypoxia and other problems caused by excess nitrogen load are not unique to the Gulf of Mexico. Recent NOAA reports indicate that the hypoxia problem occurs in more than 50% of US estuaries ("Goals unlikely to protect Gulf of Mexico shrimp industry", University of Michigan (8/4/04).).

Research from the University of Michigan shows that the current federal plan to reduce the "dead zone" in the Gulf of Mexico may not be enough to protect the region's half billion dollar a year shrimp industry. Anecdotal and sparse historic data indicating that large-scale hypoxia did not occur before the mid-1970s and supports the notion that tripling the nitrogen load over the past 50 years has led to the heightened Gulf of Mexico hypoxia problem. Hypoxia occurs when increased nitrogen runoff causes algae blooms, which sink into bottom waters and are decomposed by bacteria, a process that consumes oxygen. The warm fresh water from the Mississippi and Atchafalaya rivers also layer atop the colder salty Gulf waters, preventing atmospheric oxygen from getting to the bottom. As oxygen is consumed faster than it can be supplied, concentrations decrease below the critical 2 mg/ liter that defines hypoxia and has resulted in collapses of fisheries in other parts of the world ("Goals unlikely to protect Gulf of Mexico shrimp industry", University of Michigan (8/4/04).).

A global map of hypoxic zones is in Ref. (00W3), p. 77.

In a large region of the inner continental shelf on the coast of Louisiana and Texas, bottom water oxygen levels fall too low (under 2 mg./ liter) to support fish, crustaceans and many other vertebrates during the warmer months of April to September. This hypoxic zone, or Dead Zone, has been as large as 12,000 square miles (31,000 km2) (01B3).

By the end of July 1995, the lifeless area devoid of oxygen at the bottom of the Gulf of Mexico had grown to 7000 mi2 (18000 km2) - the largest dead zone ever recorded. Tolman attributes this dead zone to fertilizer, sewage and runoff that ends up in the Mississippi River. According to Robert Howarth at the Center for the Environment at Cornell University, the overwhelming majority of nutrient inputs into the Mississippi come from agriculture (Jonathan Tolman, Wall Street Journal (9/8/95)).

Lake Victoria the world's second-largest freshwater lake (27,000 miles2), (20% of the world's freshwater supply), is being destroyed by nutrients carried in soil from deforested land, according to International Center for Research in Agroforesty. Satellite sensing detected a plume of nitrogen-and- phosphorous-rich sediments which feed the water hyacinths, which starve fish and plankton of oxygen and sunlight, cause the lake to stagnate, and block traffic, and serve as a breeding ground for malaria-bearing mosquitoes and snails that host bilharzia, a parasite that attacks the liver, lungs and eyes. Vegetation, which used to filter the water of sediments from rivers that flow from the hills to the lake, has been removed (11/4/99 Nando Times). (la)

Runoff from farms, industries, and urban areas has resulted in 50 "dead zones" in coastal waters ("Welcome to Earth: Population 6 Billion", Christian Science Monitor 9/30/99).

Hurricane Floyd's 9/16/99 deluge (20 inches) caused floodwaters to create a growing "dead zone" in Pamlico Sound where fish and other aquatic life cannot survive. The largest affected area is a 350-square mile expanse of Pamlico Sound and part of adjacent Core Sound. Low oxygen levels were found in the bottom waters of Pamlico Sound - 1 milligram/ liter, compared to the normal 7 milligrams/ liter (Associated Press, 10/12/99).

The American Farm Bureau Federation said there is no justification for restricting fertilizers or taking land out of production. Scientists "have not established an identifiable, variable link between nitrogen fertilizer and the hypoxic zone (in the Gulf of Mexico)," the group said in comments filed with the White House science office. "No one has defined what the impact of a cutback in nitrogen fertilizer would be on nitrate levels in the Mississippi River." The gulf's "dead zone" doubled in size to about 7,000 square miles following the 1993 Midwest floods. In the summer of 1999 it expanded to 7,728 square miles, about 700 square miles larger than the previously recorded maximum of 1995. The Mississippi River drains water from 40% of the US and carries more than a million tons of nitrogen. Scientists could not identify any damage to gulf fisheries because of the oxygen depletion but warned that fisheries will "decline, perhaps precipitously," if the gulf suffers the same fate as the Black Sea and other hypoxic areas around the world (eric.uram@sfsierra.sierraclub.org, 8/17/99).

In 8,000 sq. miles of the Gulf of Mexico, no marine life exists more than 30 feet from the surface. Every spring, an infusion of nitrogen-rich fresh-water from the Mississippi River leads to the almost total depletion of oxygen in deeper waters by summer. Restoring and preserving wetland buffer zones is vital to reducing the amount of nitrogen that reaches the Mississippi in runoff from fertilizer and human waste systems (Los Angeles Times 8/8/99).

Excessive nutrients deplete oxygen in a water body, and lead to algal blooms, fish kills, lake eutrophication, etc. They have been implicated as a possible cause of hypoxia observed in several East Coast states and Pfisteria-induced fish kills and human health problems in coastal waters of several East Coast and Gulf States. The hypoxia ("Dead Zone") problem in the Gulf of Mexico is also a result of excessive nutrients. The National Water Quality Inventory: 1996 Report to Congress Executive Summary, found that the nutrients phosphorus and nitrogen caused impairment to 40% of US rivers, 51% of surveyed lakes, and 57% of surveyed estuaries (Ami Grace [cleanwaternt@igc.org], Clean Water Network June/July 1999, Status Report, 6/30/99).

Several scientists spoke on the issue of hypoxia in the Gulf of Mexico at the 1/99 AAAS meeting in Anaheim, California. Otto Doering found that farmers could use a variety of methods to cut nitrogen runoff by 20-25% without hurting food prices or farm exports. Researchers have estimated that the nitrogen load in the Mississippi River needs to be reduced by 20% in order to eliminate the Gulf's hypoxic zone. The majority of this nitrogen load is believed to originate from farms. Doering stated that 1.5 million metric tons of nitrogen are delivered to the Gulf from the Mississippi annually. Only 0.27 million metric tons can be traced to municipalities and industries. Agriculture in the Mississippi River Basin uses 6.5 million metric tons of nitrogen annually, so farm runoff is believed to be largely responsible for the excess nitrogen. Doering believes that farmers can reduce nitrogen loss by 20% with improved farm management. "Fertilizer management will be the key thing," he says. "No more fall fertilization. More precise application in terms of place and time for spring planting. Buffer zones along streams. Fewer inputs - about a 20% reduction of the amount of nitrogen used." Over-fertilization appears to be a major cause of the excess nitrogen, and Doering believes economics is a driving force behind the excessive use of nitrogen. "Nitrogen costs 18 cents/ pound and may yield an extra bushel of corn worth $2.20," he said. But even if farmers stopped putting nitrogen on fields immediately, nitrogen currently in the environment would still leak into the Mississippi. The construction of wetlands may help to reduce this leaking. "It's a way of dealing with the nitrogen already in the system," said Doering. "The wetlands allow you to hold the water for periods of time, and nitrogen tends to go into the atmosphere" (99U1).

The average size of the dead zone in the Gulf of Mexico has doubled since 1992 and now persists from May until October in some areas (99U1).

A low-oxygen "dead zone" that forms annually in the Gulf of Mexico off the Louisiana coastline covers 8,500 square miles in 2002. That's the largest yet, and larger than last year's, which was the largest yet. This year's zone is four times larger than the goal a special national task force set for reducing the annual area of low oxygen, called hypoxia, by 2015 (02D3). (continued below)

The dead zone stretches from the Mississippi River Delta across the Louisiana coast, and onto the upper Texas coast near Galveston. It covers an area from very near shore to as far as 25 miles off Grand Isle and 60 miles off Cameron, in water depths of 10-120 feet. Fresh water from the river system first flows over the heavier salt water, stratifying the water. The two-layer system inhibits the oxygen in the surface waters from penetrating to depth. Nutrients, particularly nitrogen and phosphorus, stimulate the growth of microscopic plants, the phytoplankton (02D3).

Part [A5] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Bacteria ~

The number of 1997 advisories in the US increased by 5% over 1996 to a US total of 2,299 (98U4). The number of US water bodies under advisory represents 16.6% of total US lake acres and 8.2% of total US river miles. In addition, 100% of the Great Lakes and their connecting waters and a large portion of US coastal waters remain under advisory (98U4).

In one 3-month period, 300,000 people in Shanghai came down with hepatitis-A due to clams contaminated by sewage discharges (89L1).

The 1991 cholera epidemic (300,000 cases and 3000 deaths in Peru alone) came from fish and shellfish that contacted bacteria-laden bilge water from a Chinese freighter (Ref. 56 of (94W2)).

Part [A6] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Tumors ~

Non-cancerous, but fatal, tumors called fibropapillomas are turning up in sea turtles worldwide. The prevalence of tumors in turtles found near shore areas suggests a possible link to fertilizer- or other farm-waste runoff. Some turtle habitats have infection rates of as high as 90% (Roger Featherstone, GREENLines Issue #488, 10/23/97 (Defenders of Wildlife)).

Part [A7] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Toxic Discharges ~

There are about 150 chemicals not known before 1950. Some 25% of male Mediterranean swordfish are making egg yolks, which is not something that should be happening in a male swordfish. There's this feminization being carried out by a lot of industrial chemicals. These hormone disruptors are having a big effect (09E1).

The German chemical industry poisoned the Rhine so badly that salmon, which had been plentiful as late as 1765, were rare by 1914 ((00W3), p. 7).

In 1988, 63 signatories of the London Dumping Accord also approved a ban on ocean incineration of toxic substances by 1994 (89L1).

The 8 countries bordering the North Sea agreed in 1987 to reduce nutrient- and toxic discharges by 50% by 1995 (89L1). Liquid chemical waste pours into the North Sea at over 2.1 million tons/ year (1.9 million tonnes/ year) (89L1).

In 1993, 2/3 of the US's 1279 fish-consumption advisories were issued in the Great Lakes region, mostly due to mercury, PCBs, chlordane, dioxins and DDT (95A1). Of the 30,000 different chemicals entering the Great Lakes, 362 are reliably monitored (Ref. 51 of (96A1)).

In the mid-1980s, Lake Victoria (62,000 km2) was oxygenated to its bottom - 100 meters down. Now it supports life only in the upper 40 meters or less. This is blamed, in part, on raw sewage and industrial waste from Kisumu Kenya and Mwanza Tanzania (95A1).

Several rivers running into Chesapeake Bay had outbreaks of a poisonous algae-like species called pfiesteria. These and related species have directly caused more than $1 billion of damage to the US seafood industry in the past 25 years (in addition to so-called halo effects - anti-seafood hysteria). One of the main suspected causes of these outbreaks is manure runoff from large livestock operations (97F1).

In 1993, 2/3 of the US's 1279 fish consumption advisories were issued in the Great Lakes region, mostly due to the presence of mercury, PCBs, chlordane, dioxins and DDT (96A2).

Venezuelan Audubon Society says Venezuela's Environmental Ministry is under-staffed, under-paid, rife with corruption, and mired in confusion, e.g.:

(See "Poor Protection Allows Destruction of Venezuela's Exotic Wildlife", 12/23/99 AP).

Part [A8] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Aquatic Pollution ~ Ballast Discharges ~

In 1997, Charles Moore was the first to cross upon an enormous stretch of floating plastic debris now called the "Pacific garbage patch" or the "Pacific trash vortex." This is an area in the North-Central Pacific where tiny bits of trash weighing as much as 100 million tons total, have been trapped by the currents of the North Pacific Gyre. Our research found 6-to-1 plastic to plankton by weight in 1999. In 2008: 46-to-1 plastic to plankton. Every decade, it's getting close to 10 times worse (09E1).

Ships often discharge ballast-water in harbors and coastal regions upon arrival. They also take on ballast-water in harbors and coastal waters before departure. The result is a transfer of native species to distant regions where they become alien species that can then propagate and do massive damage to native species and habitats. The fairly simple solution to this problem is to discharge ballast water in the open ocean and replace the water by open-ocean water. Ballast exchange at sea can rid ships of estuarine and coastal species taken up in port and replace them with open-water species that pose no threat to coastal waters. This could do much to reduce the introduction of alien fish species that do so much damage to native fisheries. The cost of this procedure is mainly just time. For coastal fisheries, the cost of not doing this has been exterminated fisheries and radically altered ecosystems (98W1).

WEB-SITE NAVIGATION AID - WHERE DO YOU WANT TO GO?
Go to
Top of this Chapter - Habitat Degradation
Go to
Top of this Review's Reference List
Go to
Fishery Degradation: A Global Perspective (Table of Contents)
Go to
Home Page of this entire web site
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fi8

SECTION (8-B) ~ Exotic (introduced) Species ~

Approximately 450-600 non-indigenous marine species have been added to European coastal fauna and flora, often facilitated by human-mediated processes such as shipping, aquaculture and aquaria (See Ref. (06R1) and references therein) (07A1).

Worldwide, 38% of (freshwater?) fish populations have been eliminated by exotics, compared to 17% by over-fishing (98U5).

The goby, an exotic fish specie, probably arrived in the Great Lakes from Europe in the ballast tanks of ocean-going ships. They are thriving in the Great Lakes Basin because they are aggressive, voracious feeders that can forage in total darkness. The round goby takes over spawning sites used by native species (98U5).

Before the 1970s, Lake Victoria (Uganda, Tanzania, Kenya) contained more than 350 species of fish from the cichlid family. Today over 50% of these species are extinct or found only in small populations (92W1). This was largely due to the introduction of two exotic species, the Nile perch and Nile tilapia. By 1983 Nile perch made up almost 70% of the catch, and the Nile tilapia and a native sardine made up most of the balance (90A1).

In northern Sulawesi, citizens have cleared coral reefs of harmful invasive species (99M1).

When rock bass arrived in Lake Ontario, the number of fish species in some areas diminished from 14 to 4 (98U5).

In Lakes Michigan and Huron, lamprey (a parasitic eel) caused the commercial lake trout catch to drop from 5000 tons/ year in the early 1940s to under 91 tons/ year 15 years later (95A1).

Around 1986, the Azov Sea fisheries were shut down, and the Black Sea's anchovy fisheries were virtually eliminated ($250 million/ year loss) - both due to introduction of an Atlantic Coast comb jelly (96A2).

Norway ignored its scientists' advice and imported exotic fish stocks for its aquaculture. Now they are poisoning entire rivers in an attempt to eliminate Baltic parasites and Scottish disease (97M1).

Jellyfish that Iranian officials say were carried by oil tankers threaten to ruin Iran's $34 million caviar industry (Earthweek for week ending 5/15/98 in Pittsburgh Post Gazette (5/15/98)).

SECTION (8-C) ~ Physical Habitat Degradation ~ [C1]~Bottom Trawling and Dredging, [C2]~Factory Trawlers, [C3]~Dams, [C4]~Food Supply, [C5]~Elimination, ~

Part [C1] ~ Physical Habitat Degradation ~ Bottom-Trawling and Dredging ~

The seabed in Europe has been trawled to a depth of over 1000 meters since the 1970s, degrading extensive areas of benthic habitats (07A1).

Industrial trawlers from the EU, China, Russia and elsewhere, plus many local boats have so thoroughly scoured (trawled) northwest Africa's ocean floor that major fish populations are collapsing (08L1).

Bottom trawling for fish stirs up billowing plumes that can be seen from space and destroys entire seafloor ecosystems. The technique, used worldwide, catches fish in deeper parts of the ocean with huge, deep nets, now that many near-shore fish populations have been virtually wiped out from over-fishing. Zoologist Les Watling (University of Hawaii) contends that bottom trawling is the most destructive of any actions that humans conduct in the ocean. Watling and Norse calculated that each year, worldwide, bottom trawlers drag an area equivalent to twice the area of the 48 states (February 2008 AAAS meeting). The plumes visible from satellite images are only from a small fraction of trawling activities. Plumes from deep-water trawling are not visible from space (08T1).

In 2005, the General Fisheries Commission for the Mediterranean banned trawling below depths of 1000 meters. The US closed large deep-sea areas off the coast of Alaska to bottom trawling in 2006. There are still tens of thousands of trawlers operating in the Gulf of Mexico, off the coasts of many Latin American countries, off the west coast of Africa, in Chinese waters, and in the North Sea (08T1).

A disturbing piece of videotape presented last week at the University of Texas Marine Science Institute in Port Aransas. Les Watling, professor of oceanography at the University of Maine and an expert in deep-water commercial trawling in the North Sea, showed evidence of the singular and long-lasting damage done as modern fishing trawls dig and gouge their way through bottom structure as deep as 1800 meters (00L1) (Continued below).

Corals, sponges and other desirable bottom-dwelling species have been eliminated from many areas, Watling said, replaced by less desirable plants he calls "weedy species." 80% of the animals live in the first couple of centimeters of bottom sediment, Watling said, and those are the ones displaced or destroyed by persistent trawling. Species diversity disappears. Nobody knows all the damage done by trawling. The practice has been around only about 100 years, since the advent of powerboats. However, corals at least 800 years old are being destroyed as 14.8 million km2 are trawled worldwide each year (00L1).

Between 1976 and 1992, on average, the entire bottom of the Gulf of Maine was trawled once annually, and Georges Bank was trawled 3-4 times per year (96A3). In the past decade, more than 231,000 square miles of seafloor along the US continental shelf had been trawled (02N1). (This is an area greater than that of California.)

(Global) A map of trawling areas is in Ref. (00W3), p. 80.

(Global) One estimate puts the global area swept by trawlers at 14.8 million km2 of the sea floor (/year?) ((98W5), p. 1190). Comments: Data given below indicates the area is annual area. (la)

(Global) Bottom trawls - large bag-shaped nets towed over the sea floor - account for more of the world's catch of fish, shrimp, squid and other marine animals than any other fishing method (98S3).

Some trawling rates (number per year):
Typical fishery in northern California: 1.5-3 (
02D5)
Georges Bank (40,807 km2): 3-4 (
02D5) (98S3)
Gulf of Maine 1 (98S3)
North Sea (parts of) 7 (98S3)
Australia's Queensland Coast 8 (98S3)
An area equal to that of all the world's continental shelves 0.5 (98S3)

(Global) Inter-tidal dredging has the worst impact, followed by scallop dredging and inter-tidal raking. Otter trawling and beam trawling are not as bad, as dredges tend to penetrate deeper into the sediments than trawls ("Study Analyzes Fishing Impacts on Ocean Floor", ENS (7/5/01)).

(Global) Crucial fish habitat on the ocean bottom is being ruined by fishermen who drag weighted nets to harvest fish and other seafoods such as sole, flounder, shrimp and scallops. Bottom trawling has been banned for the huge pollock fishery because of concerns about crab and halibut and other fish that were inadvertently caught in large numbers. Bottom-trawling remains in use for various kinds of sole, rockfish, cod and flounder in Alaska, and the fleet of bottom trawlers is generally regarded as having one of the worst records for catching non-target fish and seafood, called bycatch (98W3).

(Global) Loss of habitat diversity from trawling could be a major reason why so many fisheries are declining worldwide. One study shows, for instance, how young cod fish survive better in ocean habitats with more complex seabed structures. Fisheries can't survive in an underwater desert. Fish habitat is also tubeworm-, crustacean-, and anemone habitat (98F1).

(Global) Recovery of most species in (dredging-) disturbed habitats took more than 100 days, with most species recovering in closer to 500 days ("Study Analyzes Fishing Impacts on Ocean Floor", ENS (7/5/01)).

(Global) Trawling is one of the most widespread commercial fishing methods in the world. Bottom trawlers catch fish by dragging nets across the ocean floor - sometimes 2,000 meters down - behind ships or boats. The nets are held open by heavy doors and the edges of the nets have chains or metal weights that force fish and shrimp off the sea floor so they can be snared. New, more powerful fishing equipment now allows fishing even on rough bottoms like rocky reefs, which in the past were free from trawling (98F1).

(Global) The area of seabed trawled each year is nearly 150 times the area of forest that is clear-cut. Each year, trawlers drag an area of seabed twice the size of the continental US. We are doing more to the surface of the earth by trawling than perhaps any other human activity except agriculture. Like a forest, the seabed is a complex ecosystem that provides habitat and food necessary for the reproduction and growth of fish and other marine life. Trawling and dredging destroys these structures - which can take decades and even centuries to fully recover, according to the studies. After trawling, sponges, mussels, tube-dwelling worms and the crustaceans that live in disturbed areas are almost all gone. Nothing humans do to the sea has more physical impact (98F1).

(Global) Bottom trawling and dredging, two widespread but under-studied methods of commercial fishing, are the most destructive human activity affecting the world's oceans, according to new scientific studies released 12/14/98. Comparing the fishing techniques to forest clear cutting, a series of articles published in the (12/98?) scientific journal Conservation Biology warned that the living structures of sea beds are being destroyed at a rate much greater than the current rate of destruction of the earth's forests (98F1).

(Global) The overwhelming bulk of the world's trawlable shelves are impacted by fishing, leaving few sanctuaries where biomasses and biodiversity remain high (95P2). Comments: Trawler nets scrape over the bottom (often several times/ year at any given spot), leaving the ocean floor as a smooth surface devoid of features fish need for protection from predators.

(Global) Many of the world's fishing grounds are completely plowed over one to three+ times/ year by bottom trawlers (97H1).

(Global) Fishing crews have long used dragnets to scour ocean floors for bottom-dwelling cod, flounder, and similar species, but modern craft have become devastatingly efficient in grabbing everything on the floor. Diving surveillance, unavailable in earlier eras, revealed that draggers not only capture enormous proportions of the fish but sweep across vulnerable stretches of the ocean floor, destroying plants and noncommercial sea life that are the foundation of the food chain. This sea life is essential to the recovery of commercial species that are seriously depleted (98G2).

(Georges Bank) Ruthless scallop fishing methods continue to devour Georges Bank: Underwater video footage shows that a century of continuous scraping by drag-and-scrape technology has flattened the once complex seafloor environment of Georges Bank almost beyond recognition. Gone are the thousand-year-old stands of tree coral that covered hundreds of square miles of the Georges Bank plateau, providing safety and food to thousands of generations of cod, halibut and a hundred other fish species. Gone are the vast meadows of sea anemones and other soft organisms that formed a living sea floor. Gone even are the rolling underwater hills and ridgelines that guided cod on their migrations time out of mind (99H3). (Continued below)

The industry has forbidden our government to videotape or photograph them while they are carrying out their scrape- fishery. For the last 4 years, freed from this century-long scourging, wild nature out on Georges Bank has been recovering by going through a succession of plant- and animal types. The animals that first reclaim the scraped-out under-sea landscape are heavily armored creatures that can live in hostile environments - sea scallops. As these animals live and grow, their shells pile up and form a healing scab upon the scraped-over sea floor. Sea anemones, corals, sponges and other animals find these bumpy living and non-living carpets suitable to grow upon. In a normal world, the healing scab of sea scallops that has begun restoring the sea floor of the Gulf and Bank would peak and then decline. Other marine sea floor animals would take up the succession that leads to the complicated system of hundreds of different marine species (99H3).

At four years of age, the Bank's still-juvenile scallops had reached a size where they could be killed legally. Scallops can live at least 18 years. They don't produce that many eggs until they reach 10 years of age. That the scrapers would be killing juvenile scallops didn't matter. They were there, they could be killed and sold, if the scrapers were let loose among them. What was needed was an OK by the administration. Rep. Studds carried the charge to Washington DC. The power of lobbyists and money was such that even the chair of the US Senate's fisheries subcommittee couldn't stop them, though she tried (99H3).

Scrapists in more than 400 ships have invaded Georges Bank. Starting 6/15/99. Ripping away the healing scab from the Bank's sea floor -Cameras forbidden, of course. Beyond the million-plus juvenile scallops killed so far, hundreds of thousands of juvenile flounder and cod hiding within the growing scallop-mat have been killed. The partially healed seafloor of Georges Bank is being sent back to the comatose state of four years ago (99H3). (Continued below)

Unless the scrapists are removed entirely from our public undersea lands, there will be no restoration of the bounty of the wild Atlantis offshore of New England. Nothing less will bring it back. Fish habitat and scrapers simply cannot co-exist. Scraper fisheries by their very method destroy the ecosystem that lives on the sea floor (99H3). The easiest way to eliminate the scrapist attack on our undersea public lands is to end the corporate welfare that sustains them. If the annual multi-million-dollar giveaway to the scraper owners were ended, the investors who back them would drop them instantly. (Continued below)

End the welfare; break their death grip on the New England Fishery Management Council and the offshore scrapists that have ravaged Georges Bank will vanish. Once the scrapists have been swept from the seas, the scallops will rise and, their work done, fall, replaced by the coral forests and other living seafloor features that are capable of providing a limitless bounty of cod, haddock, flounder, halibut and the many other sellable fishes to the gill-netters, the tub trawlers and the rest of the fishing fleet that don't destroy fish habitat while harvesting (99H3).

("Rock-Hoppers") About 1980, fishermen developed "rock-hopper" trawl nets fitted with rubber tires that glide over rocky bottoms that would have torn earlier types of nets. Some scientists believe this gear helped hasten the collapse of New England's cod fishery by making it possible to trawl in rocky areas that served as refuges for young and breeding fish (01C1).

(Australia) A recent study by Australian scientists found that 95% of the trawled bottom in deep water off Tasmania is bare rock, vs. 10% of untouched areas (02R1).

(Australia) Shrimp trawling has reduced seabed animals by more than 50% along the 1200-mile-long Great Barrier Reef (Australia) (Area: 140,000 mile2). For every ton of prawns caught, up to 10 tons of marine life are lost (Pittsburgh Post Gazette, 2/1/99).

(Bering Sea) Large declines in crab species in the southeastern Bering Sea and Gulf of Alaska since the early 1980s parallel the growth of bottom trawling in these areas (98D2).

(Gulf of Mexico) The gulf coast of Mexico is one of the most heavily trawled areas in the world (98F1).

(North Sea) Videotape by Les Watling, professor of oceanography at University of Maine and an expert in deep-water commercial trawling in the North Sea, gives evidence of the singular and long-lasting damage done as modern fishing trawls dig and gouge their way through bottom structure as deep as 1800 meters (00L1). Corals, sponges and other desirable bottom-dwelling species have been eliminated from many areas, Watling said, replaced by less desirable plants he calls "weedy species." 80% of the animals live in the top few centimeters of bottom sediment, and those are displaced or destroyed by persistent trawling (00L1).

Part [C2] ~ Physical Habitat Degradation ~ Factory Trawlers ~

In 1994, roughly 50 factory trawlers, far less than 1% of the US fleet, caught about 20% of the fish (98N1).

(Global) 1% of the world's 3.5 million fishing boats account for at least half of the worldwide catch (98N1).

(Global) Factory ships, which account for 1% of boats and 10% of fishermen, scoop up over half of the world's catch (89U1).

(Global) New fishing vessels, combined with increasingly sophisticated fishing technology, have increased the fishing capacity of the world's industrial fleet by 22% since 1991 (98N1).

Large factory trawlers with huge, sonar-directed nets that have the ability to scoop up hundreds of tons of fish at a time (98K1). Factory trawlers' nets are as long as 0.36 km. (98D1). The largest nets can capture 400 tons of fish in a single haul. Factory trawlers stay at sea for months -fishing, processing and storing fish on board, around-the-clock, 7 days/week. Mobility permits factory trawlers to easily abandon depleted waters for fertile fishing grounds elsewhere in the world - leaving local, less mobile fishers to face the consequences of wasted ecosystems (98G1) (98D1).

The domestic US factory trawl fleet did not exist prior to 1983. It grew from 12 vessels in 1985 to 45 by the end of 1988, while catching capacity grew from 250,000 to 800,000 tonnes (98D1) (98G1). By 1992 there were 65 factory trawlers, and a $1.6 billion investment in the fleet (98G1). Additions to the fleet in 1988-90 added 15 large pollock surimi/ fillet factory trawlers with a production potential estimated to be "several times the size of the vessels which entered the fleet between 1985-87." These vessels were rebuilt in foreign countries after the passage of the Anti-Reflagging Act (1988), which Congress enacted to halt the entry of more factory trawlers into the North Pacific. However, all of these vessels ultimately received exemptions from the Coast Guard under the Act's grandfather clause (98D1).

Despite the massive global fishing fleet over-capacity, the Norwegian firm Resources Group International plans to build 24 more super-trawlers at $65 million each (98K1).

Super (factory) trawlers cost $40 million to build, can fish as deep as one mile, and can take in 400 tons of fish in a single netting (98P1).

Don Tyson (Arkansas) received over $65 million in low-interest loans to build 10 super (factory)-trawlers. The Seattle-based factory-trawler fleet has received $200 million in federal subsidies (98P1).

In the largest US fishery - that for Alaska pollock - the glut of factory trawler capacity exceeds the total allowable catch limit by at least 2-3 times. The factory trawler fleet, which has ranged between 45-65 vessels in recent years, catches nearly 20% of the total US catch. Some 36,000 smaller fishing vessels catch the rest (98D1).

Recognizing the devastating environmental potential of factory trawlers, Congress enacted measures in 1997 to prohibit the entry of large-scale fishing vessels into two important East Coast fisheries for Atlantic herring and mackerel. The catalyst for this legislation was a 369-ft. factory trawler that had set its sights on these two fisheries. This legislation was passed with significant support from both environmental- and fishing-industry groups (98D1).

Modern factory trawlers are very expensive, some costing as much as $40 million. Debts create financial pressures that are incompatible with sustainable fishing practices. Excess fishing capacity and debt-driven economics encourage wasteful, dangerous, and destructive fishing practices such as fishing heavily on spawning stocks in pursuit of the lucrative roe and "pulse fishing," where a stock or local school of fish is set upon and fished out (98D1).

About 40% of what super-trawlers catch is considered "by-catch" and is ground up and thrown back into the ocean (98P1).

In 1991, 50 factory trawlers in the pollock fishery, comprising only 2.5% of all ground-fish vessels that year, caught over 1 million tonnes of Alaska Pollock - 75% of the Bering Sea pollock quota. By 1992, there were 65 factory trawlers and an estimated $1.6 billion investment in the fleet (98D1).

The largest, and best-known, fishery for pollock was pioneered by Japanese factory trawlers in 1964, using a technique to convert the flesh into a protein paste known as surimi (98D1).

(Policy) Greenpeace believes strongly that all factory trawlers should be banned from US fisheries, as this sort of technology is incompatible with sustainable, ecologically responsible fishery management (98G1).

Bottom trawling involves use of weighted nets designed to drag on the ocean floor, churning up fish, crabs, sponges, coral and other sea life drawn into the nets (98W3).

[C3] ~ Physical Habitat Degradation ~ Dams ~

Chinese dams are blamed for low water levels in the Mekong River, a river 2976 miles long coursing through southwest China (18% of the total water volume originated in China.) Burma, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam before it enters the South China Sea. 70 million people live in the Mekong basin. Most are subsistence farmers supplementing the rice they grow with fish they catch. China has 2 hydropower dams operating on the Mekong with 2 more being built and another 4 planned. Laos has built 2 dams on a tributary of the Mekong and has 4 hydroelectric projects under construction and about a dozen others being assessed. Vietnam has one dam on the largest tributary of the Mekong and is going ahead with 3 more dams and planning two others (Barry Wain, "Depleted Mekong River Draws Concern", Wall Street Journal (9/1/04) p. B7.)

Since the Pak Mun dam (northeastern Thailand) was completed in 1994, all 150 fish species have virtually disappeared from the Mun River (96A2).

The Diama Barrage on the Senegal River, built to prevent incursion of salt water during periods of low river flow, is expected to cause the annual loss of 7,000 tons of shrimp and fish (95M1).

Dams in northern Nigeria have lowered freshwater fish catches by over 50% (Ref. 40 of (96A2)).

Since World War II we have seen greatly renewed activities on water development programs in western waters. Salmon and steelhead resources of streams draining into the Pacific Ocean are worth over $100,000,000/ year to the Pacific Northwest economy. In California, Oregon, and Washington practically every major stream is under scrutiny for what it might produce in terms of power, irrigation, flood control and navigation. These are the four arguments that back every recommendation made to the Congress. There are a series of power, irrigation, and flood control dam sites under study in the region of the world-famous Rogue River in southern Oregon, most of which, if built, will cause irreparable harm to a resource that brings to the Pacific Coast area over $2,155,000/ year from sports fishermen (49N1).

Any fishery biologist will tell you that flood control reservoirs make poor homes for fish. The fluctuating fore bay levels periodically desiccate out all fish foods dwelling in the richer, shallow-water areas, with the result that many soon become biological deserts barren of foods and fish alike (49N1).

Part [C4] ~ Physical Habitat Degradation ~ Food Supply ~

(Newfoundland) The collapse of the capelin fishery off Newfoundland in the late 1970s produced negative effects on populations of harp seals and humpback whales (98D2).

(Norway) In the Barents Sea off Norway, the collapse of herring stocks in the 1960s and capelin in the mid-1980s is linked to big declines in cod abundance in the mid-1980s (98D2).

(Alaska) From the late 1970s to the late 1980s, the largest Pacific harbor seal rookery in the world at Tugidak (south of Kodiak) suffered an 86% decline in population, parallel to and following the period of record-high pollock harvests in the Shelikof Strait. (Pollock comprised the single largest source of prey for harbor seals.) (98D2).

Part [C5] ~ Physical Habitat Degradation ~ Elimination (of habitat) ~

Many spawning grounds have been cleared to make room for shrimp ponds, golf courses, and beach resorts. As a result of habitat degradation, insured coastal property damages in the US soared to $50 billion in the 1990s (99M1).

WEB-SITE NAVIGATION AID - WHERE DO YOU WANT TO GO?
Go to
Top of this Chapter-Habitat Degradation
Go to
Top of this Review's Reference List
Go to
Fishery Degradation: A Global Perspective (Table of Contents)
Go to
Home Page of this entire web site
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fi8

SECTION (8-D) ~ Atmospheric Effects ~ [D1]~Ozone, [D2]~Ocean Temperatures, [D3]~Acid Precipitation, ~

Part [D1] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Atmospheric Effects ~ Ozone ~

Increased atmospheric ozone levels may already have decreased phytoplankton yields in the Antarctic Ocean (92S1).

In Antarctica, thinning of the ozone layer may account for the "dramatic" decline of a key marine species. Krill (food for whales and penguins) population off the Antarctic Peninsula, south of Tierra del Fuego, is 25% of what it was in the mid-1980s. More of the sun's ultraviolet radiation is reaching the Earth's surface, killing plankton on which krill feed (1/2/00 Tokyo Asahi Shimbun).

Krill, the little shrimps at the heart of the Antarctic food chain, are in double danger from climate change and the likelihood of greatly increased fishing. New Australian research shows krill are highly sensitive to ultraviolet light from the hole in the ozone layer while conservationists fear an American corporation is gearing up to massively increase krill fishing in the Antarctic (99W1).

A serious decline in krill, and some decline already appears to be happening, could have a disastrous impact on seals, penguins, whales and sea birds, scientists said. Laboratory tests showed krill was more susceptible to UV than any other animal. Krill is already under pressure from warmer air temperatures and reduced ice cover (99W1).

Krill spends part of its time near the surface and part at depths between 50-100 meters, where it is protected from UV (99W1).

Part [D2] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Atmospheric Effects ~ Ocean Temperatures ~

Biologists have known for years that global warming is linked to declining fish stocks, but a new study of eelpouts is the first to see how warmer seas are linked to how fishes take in oxygen. Researchers not only found that the oxygen levels in the waters of the North Sea and Baltic Sea have dropped over the past 50 years, a factor that reduces fish populations. They also found that eelpouts need more oxygen in warmer waters. Difficulty in taking up oxygen caused by the warming waters, proved to be the key factor. The population of eelpouts dropped as average summer temperatures increased. Animals tolerate a limited range of environmental conditions. Fish in the North Sea tolerate a wider range of temperatures than fish elsewhere. However, warming waters can stress fish to the point that their thermal tolerance range is thrown off and they perish. Warming waters can be expected to strain species that require lots of oxygen, forcing them to either relocate to cooler waters or face extinction ("Columbia: Warming Seas Send Big-headed Fish Deeper; Eelpouts Seek Out Colder Water, Are Hurt by Drop in Oxygen Levels," MSNBC.com (1/04/07).).

As ocean surface waters warm up, phytoplankton biomass decline. Changes in ocean color detected from space allow researchers to calculate their photosynthetic rates and correlate these changes to the climate. As rising air temperatures heat up the ocean's surface, this water separates from the cold layer below, which is full of nutrients. Phytoplankton (the bottom of the marine food chain) needs sunlight for photosynthesis, and the floating plants are separated from nutrients. When phytoplankton is abundant, the water color shifts from blue to green. Phytoplankton remove carbon dioxide and convert it to organic carbon. During periods of cooler temperatures, there is a flowering of these marine plants (phytoplankton) as in late 1999 when the oceans were recovering from a strong El Nino. But between 2000 and the present (2006), as the oceans warmed, phytoplankton productivity declined by 190 million tons of carbon/ year. Every 2-6 days, predators eat the entire global phytoplankton mass. This very fast turnover, along with the fact that phytoplankton are a thin veneer of the ocean surface where there is enough sunlight to sustain photosynthesis, makes them very responsive to changes in climate. As carbon dioxide levels rise, and phytoplankton production decreases, there is less ocean plant life to consume this greenhouse gas via the normal photosynthetic processes ("New Data Show Global Warming Kills Marine Life," The Independent (12/07/2006).).

In a paper published in Science, John A. McGowan of the Scripps Institution of Oceanography documented a 20-year-long rise in Pacific Ocean temperatures. McGowan says the warmer temperatures have harmed a variety of sea creatures, from zooplankton to fur seals to sooty shearwaters, a gull-sized sea bird that has declined by 90% off California (98M3).

Part [D3] ~ Habitat Degradation ~ Atmospheric Effects ~ Acid Precipitation ~

(Norway) Incidents of acid precipitation causing fish deaths in parts of Norway are described in Ref. (94H3).

(Nova Scotia) A Canadian scientist contends that "gene banking" may be the only way to save wild Atlantic salmon from a "full-scale disaster" caused by acid rain on Nova Scotia's eastern shore says. "More than half" of Nova Scotia's 65 rivers are too acidic for salmon, and only 13 rivers can support naturally reproducing salmon (Bangor Daily News (10/25/00)).

(Europe) About 40% of toxic pollution in Europe's coastal waters is thought to stem from atmospheric deposition. The percentage could be greater in the open ocean (91T1) (98E1).

WEB-SITE NAVIGATION AID - WHERE DO YOU WANT TO GO?
Go to
Top of this Chapter - Habitat Degradation
Go to
Top of this Review's Reference List
Go to
Fishery Degradation: A Global Perspective (Table of Contents)
Go to
Home Page of this entire web site
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fi8